The Real
Treasure Island
By
Land ~ Sea Discovery Group Staff
AUTHORS
PRELUDE:
In 1958
when I was a wee lad of eight years I was confined to my bedroom
for what seemed like months with bronchial asthma. Many days I
stared out the window watching as the other kids got to play in
the outdoors. All I could do was dream of the day that I too could
be outside. I spent hours playing with tin soldiers having mock
battles on my bed sheets and in the more restful periods I read
and reread my favorite book by Robert Louis Stevenson "Treasure
Island." His story of treasure buried on a remote island
fueled my dreams for many months until I was cured and it left
in me this wonderful sense of adventure that I still carry with
me today. It was only recently that I learned that Stevenson’s
"Treasure Island" was based on a real place called Cocos
Island.

Treasure Island by Robert Louis Stephenson |
"Land
ho!" Came the shout from above in the crows’ nest.
It was a most welcome sound for the crew and passengers aboard
the schooner Vanderbuilt. The date was November 2, in the year
of our lord 1879 and as the ship sailed into the harbor at Santa
Barbara, California these people happy again to see shore were
also searching for a way to slip away from the crowds gathered
on the dock to greet them.
Was this strange behavior? Not really, for these poor souls were
returning from a gold less treasure hunting trip to Cocos Island
and wanted to avoid questioning and embarrassments due to their
failure.
The ship
sailed from San Francisco on April 12 of 1879 loaded with adventurers
and provisions with the final destination being the world known
Cocos Island. For three months the crew and passengers dug holes
and tunnels, ditches and even changed the course of some streams
in search of the treasures on Cocos Island. Their search was in
vain and soon they were forced to head home. It was a long, disheartening
journey. Already beaten by the Islands impenetrability, they now
faced calm seas and light head winds, causing a long 66-day voyage
to a friendly port. Provisions ran out long before reaching port
with the exception of flour and tea, which they survived on for
the last twelve days at sea.

The Lost Treasure of Cocos Island
|
For many years
before this expedition in 1879 and as early as 1841 this island
has been the source of great expense to treasure hunters world
wide and still to this decade treasure hunters are trying their
luck on Cocos Island. Records show that over 450 expeditions have
taken place and only a little have been printed showing successes
in any of the ventures. In England during the 1920's and 30's
they had a virtual treasure boom with articles being printed daily
about pirates and buccaneers. Of all the stories Cocos was the
one that actually motivated men of all walks of life to set sail
and put aside their day-to-day routines. British Admirals, English
Lords, New York and San Francisco businessmen, and even our Franklin
D. Roosevelt paid visits to the island.
What drove these men
to try and try again where others before may have failed? Was
it the dreams of a child and finding pirate gold, or greed, or
maybe the sheer magnitude of the treasures supposedly buried there.
After all, over $100,000,000 in treasure can be quite an inspiration
to one able to finance a trip to Cocos Island.
Cocos Island is west
of Costa Rica roughly 500 miles. The Island is named for its vast
groves of coconut trees. The Island is roughly 20 square miles
of dense jungle with cliffs that rise up from the ocean 200 to
600 feet. The two bays, Wafer and Chatham are the only safe places
to anchor and were frequented often by pirates and buccaneers
who found it a good watering spot. The land of the interior is
steep and very difficult to traverse even for the gold craving
treasure hunter.
It is believed that
the first treasures were deposited on the misty veiled island
by the pirate Edward Davis and the crew of his captured Danish
ship the Bachelors Delight. This motley crew leisurely sailed
up and down the coast of South America taking Spanish ships and
looting Spanish villages. When his coffers were full he would
sail to Cocos, bury the loot, and clean his ship. In time Edward
Davis commanded over 1000 buccaneers. They looted the city of
Leon in Nicaragua and he again returned to Cocos to bury yet more
treasures. It has been estimated that millions were left on the
island. Wafer Bay is incidentally named after Davis's surgeon
and naturalist.
The Franco-Spanish
pirate Captain William Dampier, a privateer turned pirate used
the brig Relampago to loot the coast of South America also, and
it is said that he buried at least $60,000. in sandstone caves
on Cocos Island. On the southern side of the island is a spot
named Dampier Head.
Between 1819
and 1820 a Portuguese by the name of Benito Bonito arrived at
the coast of Mexico, near Acapulco after he had spent years pillaging
the West Indies and the coasts of Chile and Peru. It was Mexico's
turn to pay the pirate. He and his crew lay in wait for the fabulously
rich burro trains going from Mexico City to the coast and further
shipment to Spain. The trains were easy prey and soon he and his
bloodthirsty crew sailed for Cocos Island where they buried 300,000
pounds of silver and the spoils from their adventures in the West
Indies. The men headed for Cape Horn where all but one of the
crew died in battle with a British warship the Espiegle

Bronze pirate and treasure chest figure |
The greatest
part of the Cocos Islands lure of treasure however is the loot from
Lima. Spain was losing its grip on the Americas and around the year
1820 Simon Bolivar was conducting a revolution in Peru. The aristocrats
who represented Spain's interests were worried about the impending
invasions into Lima and sought to protect their immense fortune
from the rebels. The 60 or so churches were in the same predicament.
The two groups stripped their vaults and churches of everything
that was gold or silver and had it all transported to the fort at
the seaport of Calleo were they thought it would be safe. Before
long they realized that the rebels would stop at nothing to take
the country and decided to ship the treasure out to sea until the
revolution was over or until they could find a safe place to store
the treasure and send it back to Spain.
A Captain Thompson
who was well known by the Peruvians as a fair man, was approached
as his ship the Mary Dier lay at anchor in the bay. They asked
if he would take on the treasure, some priests and some guards
and sail out into the open sea and wait until the coast was clear.
He agreed to do the job for a handsome price. Once out to sea
the crew and the Captain having loaded this immense treasure could
not resist the temptation to own it for themselves. They proceeded
to club the Peruvian guards and slashed the throats of the priests
then tossed them all overboard. The Mary Deir then headed for
Cocos Island where it took eleven trips in the ship's longboat
to get the treasure from the ship to shore. They buried the treasure
with all intentions of returning in a year or so after all the
fuss had quieted down. The treasure was valued at roughly 12 million
in an1820's market. Today it would be worth over $100,000,000.
Another prize buried at that time was a solid gold, gem encrusted,
life-sized statue of the Virgin Mary. They say it weighed a ton.
After unloading the ship this group turned pirate, headed round
the Horn towards England but before they reached the Horn a Spanish
warship captured them and sent them all to Panama to be put on
trial for murder and piracy. They were all convicted and sentenced
to be hung, which they all promptly were with the exception of
the Capt. and his mate, who they hoped would bargain their lives
for the where abouts of the treasure. Once the two men and their
guards reached the shore of Cocos Island, the Captain and his
mate took off and hid in the dense foliage of the island. The
Spaniards finally gave up looking for them after searching fruitlessly
for days and returned to Panama. Captain Thompson and the mate
stayed marooned on the island for many long months surviving on
bird’s eggs, fruit, coconuts, and small game. Eventually
they were rescued by whalers and ended up in Newfoundland. Thompson
died and the mate a man named Keating produced a map of the treasure
and from that point on people tried to finance expeditions to
the island.
Since then real and
fake maps have fallen from out of the pages of books, from between
the linings of steamer trunks and virtually every nook and cranny
to lead adventurers to the island. Distant relatives of pirates
and seamen claim to have the exclusive charts to the islands treasure.
The sources of treasure
on the island are as numerous as the expeditions to find them
and many are constantly being rebutted by scholars, historians,
and treasure hunters alike. Like Americas Lost Dutchman’s
mine, and Nova Scotia’s Oak Island, people believe that
there must be some truth to the stories, enough truth to spend
millions trying to find lost treasure.
SOURCE
DOCUMENTATION;
1. B. A. Tomkins,
Treasure, Times Books, 1979
2. Ralph Hancock and Julian A. Weston, The Lost Treasure of Cocos
Island, Thomas Nelson & Sons,1960.
3. Edward Rowe Snow, True Tales of Pirates and Their Gold, Dodd,
Mead, & Co., 1957
4. Robert Nesmith, Dig For Pirate Treasure, The Devin-Adair Company,
1958
5. Harold T. Wilkins, Treasure Hunting, Rio Grande Press, 1939.